How to Choose a Franchise Lawyer: 7 Key Questions | Lopes Law LLC - Lopes Law LLC | National Franchise Law Firm

How to Choose a Franchise Lawyer: 7 Key Questions | Lopes Law LLC

Franchise Law Basics

How to Choose a Franchise Lawyer: 7 Questions to Ask

How to Choose a Franchise Lawyer: 7 Questions to Ask - Lopes Law LLC

Choosing a franchise lawyer requires evaluating franchise-specific experience, billing transparency, both-sides experience (representing franchisors and franchisees), state law knowledge, communication standards, and clarity of deliverables. The hourly rate is the least important factor on that list. A $250-per-hour general business attorney who does not understand the FTC Franchise Rule or state registration laws can cost you far more in missed risks than a $400-per-hour dedicated franchise attorney would have charged for the same engagement. The question is not how much the attorney charges. The question is whether they are genuinely qualified to protect your specific interests in a franchise transaction.

This guide gives you 7 specific questions to ask before hiring any franchise attorney, along with the red flags that tell you to keep looking.

Why Are General Business Attorneys Not Enough for Franchise Work?

Franchise law is not a subset of business law in the way that real estate law or employment law are. It is governed by its own federal regulation: the FTC Franchise Rule (16 CFR Part 436), enforced by the Federal Trade Commission, which sets mandatory disclosure requirements applicable nationwide. Fourteen states have layered their own franchise investment laws on top of the federal rule, requiring state-level registration and compliance filings. Several of those states also have franchise relationship laws that grant franchisees specific rights in termination, renewal, and transfer situations that cannot be waived by contract.

A general business attorney who “does some franchise work” alongside corporate formations, real estate closings, and employment contracts is not the same as a dedicated franchise attorney. The specialized knowledge required to identify risk in a 23-item FDD, to understand what provisions are standard versus unusual in a franchise agreement, to know which state relationship laws apply to your specific situation, and to advise on realistic negotiating leverage takes years of focused franchise practice to develop.

Client scenario: A prospective franchisee came to Lopes Law LLC after receiving an FDD review from his general business attorney. The attorney delivered a two-page letter identifying some basic concerns about the royalty rate and the renewal fee. What the letter did not identify: a clause allowing the franchisor to terminate with only 30 days notice for failure to meet annual minimum royalties set at a level the franchisee had no realistic chance of meeting in year one; an Item 20 attrition rate of 22% (indicating nearly one in four franchisees had left the system in the prior three years); a mandatory arbitration clause requiring all disputes to be resolved in the franchisor’s home state of Texas; and a cross-default provision linking the franchise agreement to a separate supply agreement with automatic termination triggers. These are the types of issues a general business attorney without franchise-specific experience often misses entirely.

Question 1: Do You Focus Exclusively on Franchise Law?

This is the most important question to ask, and the answer tells you more than anything else about whether the attorney is qualified for your matter. You are looking for an attorney whose practice is centered on franchise law, not one who handles franchise matters occasionally alongside a general business practice.

Acceptable answer: “Franchise law is my primary practice area. I represent franchisees and franchisors on FDD reviews, franchise agreement negotiations, dispute resolution, and franchise development.”

Concerning answer: “I handle all kinds of business matters. I have reviewed a few franchise agreements in the past and I am familiar with the general concepts.”

If the attorney cannot cite specific franchise matters they have handled recently, specific franchise brands they have reviewed, or specific franchise law statutes they are familiar with, you are talking to a generalist who may not have the depth you need.

Question 2: Have You Represented Both Franchisors and Franchisees?

Both-sides experience matters because understanding how franchisors structure their agreements, where they have built-in flexibility, and how their legal teams respond to negotiation requests gives a franchisee attorney a significant advantage. An attorney who has only ever represented franchisees may not know which FDD provisions are genuinely non-negotiable (most) versus which ones franchisors regularly modify for the right buyer (some).

At Lopes Law LLC, Anthony Lopes has represented both franchisors (in FDD development, state registration, and ongoing compliance) and franchisees (in FDD reviews, agreement negotiations, and dispute resolution) for over 15 years. That experience on both sides of the table informs every franchisee review we conduct: we know what the franchisor’s attorneys were thinking when they drafted particular provisions, and we know where the realistic negotiating opportunities are.

Question 3: What Specific Deliverable Will I Receive?

This question filters out attorneys who provide vague, informal “reviews” and surfaces those who deliver structured, written analysis. You are entering a 10-year legally binding relationship. You deserve a written record of the legal analysis you received, not just a phone call and a general impression.

What you should receive from a quality FDD review:

  • A written report organized by FDD item (not a short letter summarizing general impressions)
  • Analysis of every significant provision in the franchise agreement, not just the fee items
  • Identification of specific provisions that are unusual or favorable to the franchisor relative to industry norms
  • Specific negotiating recommendations, where applicable
  • Analysis of Item 20 attrition data
  • Summary of state-specific protections if you are buying in a registration state

At Lopes Law LLC, our FDD validation review delivers a written report of 15 to 20 pages, organized by FDD item and franchise agreement section. You receive it within 5 to 7 business days. You can schedule a follow-up call to discuss findings, and reasonable follow-up questions are included in the flat fee.

Question 4: What Is Your Total Cost and What Is Included?

Before engaging any attorney, you need to know three things: the total cost, what that cost covers, and what might add to it. For flat fee attorneys, this is straightforward: the fee is quoted upfront and should not change for work within the defined scope. For hourly attorneys, insist on a written estimate and ask specifically what would cause the total to be higher than the estimate.

Questions to ask about billing:

  • “Is the franchise agreement review included in the FDD review fee, or is it a separate charge?”
  • “Are follow-up questions after the review included, or billed separately?”
  • “Are state filing fees or government fees included, or billed at cost separately?”
  • “If the scope changes, how will you notify me and what happens to the fee?”

For a comprehensive guide to franchise attorney billing models, see our post on flat fee vs. hourly franchise lawyer billing. For an overview of all current market pricing for franchise legal services, see our guide on how much a franchise lawyer costs.

Question 5: Are You Familiar With My State’s Franchise Laws?

If you are purchasing or operating a franchise in one of the 14 registration states, your attorney should have specific knowledge of that state’s franchise investment law and relationship law protections. These states have requirements that go significantly beyond the federal FTC Franchise Rule:

  • California: The California Franchise Investment Law and the California Franchise Relations Act provide robust franchisee protections including good cause requirements for termination and strong renewal rights.
  • Illinois: The Illinois Franchise Disclosure Act requires registration and includes a 180-day cure period for many defaults, significantly stronger than most franchise agreement cure provisions.
  • Minnesota: The Minnesota Franchise Act includes strong relationship law protections, right to associate, and restrictions on non-renewal.
  • Washington: The Washington Franchise Investment Protection Act requires good cause for termination and provides franchisees significant protection in dispute situations.

Choice of law provisions in franchise agreements can sometimes override state protections if not carefully analyzed. An attorney unfamiliar with state franchise relationship laws may miss whether a choice of law clause is enforceable in your state or whether state protections apply regardless of the agreement’s terms.

Talk to a Dedicated Franchise Attorney Before You Sign

At Lopes Law LLC, franchise law is our focus. Not business law in general. Not a mix of practice areas. Franchise law. Free 20-minute consultation to discuss your situation.

Question 6: What Is Your Timeline and Communication Process?

Franchise transactions have time pressure. You have a 14-day waiting period from FDD receipt to signing. The FDD has an expiration date. Discovery Days are scheduled. Franchise sales representatives may be following up. In this environment, an attorney who takes 3 weeks to return calls or cannot commit to a review timeline creates real practical problems.

Ask specifically:

  • “How long will the FDD review take after I send you the documents?”
  • “What is your preferred method of communication and typical response time?”
  • “Will you be personally handling my matter, or will it be delegated to a junior associate?”
  • “How do you communicate findings: written report, phone call, or email?”

At Lopes Law LLC, we deliver FDD validation reviews within 5 to 7 business days of receiving complete documents. We communicate by written report with a follow-up call available to discuss findings. Managing partner Anthony Lopes personally reviews all FDD matters and is directly accessible to clients throughout the process.

Question 7: Can You Provide a Reference From a Similar Matter?

An experienced franchise attorney should be able to provide at least one or two references from clients who have engaged them for similar work. A franchisee who hired the attorney for an FDD review, a franchisor who used them for FDD development, or a client who navigated a franchise dispute with their assistance. References provide information that credentials and marketing materials cannot.

If an attorney is reluctant to provide any references or cannot identify any former clients willing to speak about their experience, that is a yellow flag. Most satisfied clients are willing to provide a brief reference for an attorney they were genuinely happy with.

Red Flags When Evaluating Franchise Attorneys

Beyond the seven questions, watch for these specific behaviors during your attorney evaluation:

At Lopes Law LLC, we have consulted with franchise buyers who previously engaged attorneys that exhibited one or more of these red flags. In several cases, the buyer’s prior attorney had completed a “review” that consisted of a 15-minute phone call and no written deliverable. The buyer signed the franchise agreement believing they had received legal review, only to discover significant issues months later. The cost of correcting those issues was many times higher than the cost of a proper review would have been.

  • Pressure to engage quickly: A legitimate franchise attorney will never pressure you to engage without fully explaining the process, the cost, and the timeline. Pressure tactics suggest the attorney’s business development interests are ahead of your informed consent.
  • Claims that they can negotiate “any term” in the agreement: Most franchise agreements have areas of limited flexibility. An attorney who claims they can change the royalty structure, the territory provisions, or the term of the agreement without knowing anything about the specific franchise system is overpromising. Legitimate negotiation opportunities exist, but they are specific and system-dependent.
  • Vague or unavailable billing information: If an attorney cannot give you a clear cost estimate before you engage, that is a problem. You should know your cost before you commit, regardless of whether the billing model is hourly or flat fee.
  • No written deliverable described: If the attorney cannot tell you what you will receive when the review is complete, that is a significant concern. A verbal review with a brief phone call is not adequate for a transaction of this magnitude.
  • No familiarity with the specific franchise brand: While it is not realistic to expect every attorney to have reviewed every franchise brand, an experienced franchise attorney should be able to tell you whether they are familiar with the general category of franchise (restaurant, service, health, retail) and whether anything about the particular FDD stood out as unusual relative to comparable systems.

Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Franchise Lawyer

Why Are General Business Attorneys Not Enough for Franchise Work? +
Franchise law is a specialized practice area governed by the FTC Franchise Rule (16 CFR Part 436), state franchise investment laws in 14 registration states, and franchise relationship laws that provide franchisee protections beyond what is in the agreement. A general business attorney who handles some franchise matters alongside other business work is unlikely to have the depth of experience to identify franchise-specific risks, negotiation opportunities, or state law protections that a dedicated franchise attorney recognizes immediately.
What Specific Deliverable Will I Receive from an FDD Review? +
At Lopes Law LLC, the deliverable for an FDD validation review is a written report, typically 15 to 20 pages, organized by FDD item and franchise agreement section. The report identifies material risks, flags negotiable provisions, summarizes Item 19 financial performance representations (if any), analyzes Item 20 attrition data, and provides specific recommended action items. You receive this within 5 to 7 business days and can schedule a follow-up call to discuss findings.
Do You Need a Franchise Lawyer in Your State? +
Franchise law is primarily federal (the FTC Franchise Rule), which means a franchise attorney does not need to be licensed in your state to review your FDD and franchise agreement. However, if you are buying in one of the 14 registration states, your attorney should have specific knowledge of that state’s franchise investment law and relationship law protections. At Lopes Law LLC, Managing Partner Anthony Lopes is admitted to the Pennsylvania Bar, and the firm advises clients in all states on franchise matters.
Have You Represented Both Franchisors and Franchisees? +
Both-sides experience matters because understanding how franchisors structure their systems, write their agreements, and respond to franchisee concerns gives an attorney a more complete picture of where real negotiating leverage exists. At Lopes Law LLC, Anthony Lopes has represented both franchisors (in FDD development, registration, and compliance) and franchisees (in FDD reviews, agreement negotiations, and dispute resolution) for over 15 years.
What Red Flags Should You Watch for When Evaluating a Franchise Attorney? +
Red flags include: inability to describe specific franchise law experience, vague billing that cannot be quoted upfront, no clear description of the deliverable, pressure to engage quickly without explaining the process, claims that the attorney can negotiate any term in the franchise agreement, and unfamiliarity with the specific franchise brand you are evaluating.

How Lopes Law LLC Answers These 7 Questions

It would be unfair to lay out a framework for choosing a franchise attorney without applying it to ourselves. Here is how Lopes Law LLC answers the seven questions we have outlined:

We share this not as a sales pitch but because transparency is the standard we ask you to hold every franchise attorney to, including us. If any attorney cannot answer these questions clearly and directly, that tells you something about how they will handle your matter.

  1. Do you focus exclusively on franchise law? Yes. Our practice is built on franchise law for both franchisors and franchisees, supplemented by international franchise work and related transactional matters.
  2. Have you represented both franchisors and franchisees? Yes. Anthony Lopes has represented franchisors in FDD development and state registration and franchisees in FDD reviews, agreement negotiation, and dispute resolution for 15+ years, including experience at Duane Morris LLP and in-house at a pharmaceutical company.
  3. What specific deliverable will I receive? A written report of 15 to 20 pages organized by FDD item, delivered in 5 to 7 business days, with follow-up call available.
  4. What is your total cost and what is included? FDD validation review: $3,000 flat, inclusive of franchise agreement analysis and follow-up questions. No hourly surprises.
  5. Are you familiar with my state’s franchise laws? Yes. We advise clients nationally and have specific knowledge of registration state requirements and relationship law protections.
  6. What is your timeline and communication process? 5 to 7 business day delivery on FDD reviews. Managing partner-level attention on all matters. Written report plus follow-up call.
  7. Can you provide a reference? Yes. We are happy to provide references from former clients on request.

For more context on what our review process involves, read our detailed guide on what an FDD review includes. For a complete pricing overview, see our post on how much a franchise lawyer costs.

Reach out, we are friendly. Call now for a free consultation at (267) 777-9117 or schedule your free 20-minute consultation online.

Find the Right Franchise Lawyer for Your Situation

Lopes Law LLC offers franchise-specialized legal services with transparent flat fees and a written deliverable every time. Free 20-minute consultation.

Scroll to Top